Home
About Us
Search
Site Map
Contact Us
Research Ethics Program
Courses
Seminar Series
Resources
What's New?
Biomedical Ethics Seminar Series
 Back to Calendar 2004

Wednesday, March 17, 2004

Topic: Embryonic Stem Cell Chimera Research: What is it? What are its benefits? What concerns does it raise?
Presenter: Mark Mercola, Ph.D.
Professor, Stem Cell and Regeneration Program, The Burnham Institute
Adjunct Professor, Dept. of Pathology, UCSD
Location: Medical Teaching Facility (MTF) 175
Presentation
Abstract :
Our aim will be to examine the promise of this research in the context of moral (and possibly biological) concerns about creating interspecies beings.
Discussion
Questions:
Some issues for discussion:
  1. What is chimera research and why do we want to do it?

  2. What is the source of moral unease with such research? What moral boundaries does the creation of chimeras, or interspecies beings, breach?

  3. Is species identity fixed biologically or are the boundaries between species fluid?

  4. Given the genetic similarity between Homo Sapiens and other species, what makes human and nonhuman hybrids morally problematic?

  5. Lastly, how are reasonable concerns about crossing species boundaries to be weighed against the possible benefits of this research?
Discussion
Summary:
Readings:
  • Rosenthal, N. Prometheus's Vulture and the Stem-Cell Promise. NEJM Vol. 349, No. 3. 2003. pp. 267-274

  • Robert, J.S. Crossing Species Boundaries. American Journal of Bioethics Vol. 3, No. 3. 2003

Note: Electronic access to the essays specified above is available through electronic Reserves in the UCSD Biomedical Library. Website is http://reserves.ucsd.edu. Search "Devereaux" or "SOM 100". Click on the link for the course page, accept the copyright statement and you will be able to view the pdf files.