Home
About Us
Search
Site Map
Contact Us
Research Ethics Program
Courses
Seminar Series
Resources
What's New?
Biomedical Ethics Seminar Series
 Back to Calendar 2004

Wednesday, July 21, 2004

Topic: Traversing An Ethical Minefield: The Continuing Stem Cell Debate
Presenter: Evan Snyder, Professor & Director
Stem Cell & Regeneration Program
The Burnham Institute
Location: Medical Teaching Facility (MTF) 175
Presentation
Abstract :
Scientists believe that stem cell research offers great promise for understanding and harnessing the power of cells to regenerate and repair themselves, thus opening the door to cures for a range of debilitating diseases, including diabetis, Parkinson's, MS, ALS and heart disease.

Despite its far-reaching clinical potential, stem cell research continues to elicit strong public opposition. Critics argue that the destruction of early stage embryos is ethically impermissible, even to advance medically worthy ends.
Discussion
Questions:
Dr. Snyder will examine the current state of the stem cell debate with attention to the following issues:
  1. What kind of moral consideration is owed the early embryo?

  2. At what point in its development does a human organism deserve full moral respect (equal that of an adult human being or a child)?

  3. Is convergence possible among the differing points of view on the status of the human embryo? How effective a "compromise" Is the Bush policy restricting public funding to stem cell lines established before the announced cut off date?

  4. What are the aims of the California Stem Cell Initiative and is it likely to pass?
Discussion
Summary:
Readings:
  • Snyder, E.Y. (et al). "Taking Stock and Planning for the Next Decade: Realistic Prospects for Stem Cell Therapies for the Nervous System." Journal of Neuroscience Research, v.76. 2004. pp. 157-168.

  • Rothstein, J.D. (et al)." Reality and immortality - neural stem cells for therapies." Nature Biotechnology, 22 (3). 2004. pp. 283-285.

Note: Electronic access to the essays specified above is available through electronic Reserves in the UCSD Biomedical Library. Website is http://reserves.ucsd.edu. Search "Devereaux" or "SOM 100". Click on the link for the course page, accept the copyright statement and you will be able to view the pdf files.